PhotoPost PHP Pro or vBGallery?

[Burns]

Hi,

I did a search and even found some threads comparing the both PP galleries, but I'm still not sure regarding some aspects and even the latest thread I found was quite old ( A Good Photo Gallery? )

It looks like PhotoPost PHP Pro & vBGallery both lack some features that I'd like to have, so the most important question is - are there some hacks or/and how easy it would be to make a hack to add the desired features. I changed a lot in my vBulletin (v.3.0.7) even though it took me many months (I hope the gallery modifications will not take that long).

What I like in PhotoPost PHP Pro :

1) Recent Comments (I don't really need the latest/random images, but the latest comments(along with thumbnails) and the way they're displayed in PhotoPost is nice)
I've never seen a vBGallery with "latest comments" section in Home.

2) Multiple tags/keywords (assigned to the same image/media file), search by a single click on these keywords

3) From the PP comparision list:
- Optional thumbnail upload for Video files,
- Multimedia/Video Support,
- Upload photos in ZIP's
( not very important, but still a nice bonus )


What I don't like in PhotoPost PHP Pro (or at least in the version PhotoPost PHP vB3 Enhanced installed on one of my fav. sites) :

1) There seems to be a search bug - some of the search parameters are lost once you click on the link to the 2nd page!
( first found "Images 1 to 12 of 56", 5 pages --> click on the 2nd page --> "Images 13 to 24 of 90", 8 pages,
searched for Username + keyword + time (1 month) ; it looks like the time filter doesn't work after selecting page 2)
[ if it's an old bug that was fixed already, may I ask if bugs like this are typical for PhotoPost? ]

2) The users' online status is not adjusted according to the "Invisible" option. The "Invisible" users are displayed as "Online".

3) Keywords: in the forum mentioned above the keywords are not always useful.
Example: "Men in Black" is stored as "Men", "in", "Black". Not sure if quote marks can be used, I never saw anyone using it. In fact some people seem to be so desperate that they write "Men_in_Black" (but this is not a good solution).
I'd like to be able to enter in Keywords: Men in Black, action which would result in keywords "Men in Black" and "action" being assigned to the image.


What I don't remember seeing in either gallery (I'm sorry, my fav. vBG gallery is down atm, I can't check it) :

1) I want to let the users to choose which sections of the gallery they want to see. Without this option even "Recent Comments" feature (that is one of my fav. features) is not very useful. A solution with help of joinable groups might me acceptable, even though I'd prefer a separate add/remove function (in forum or gallery options, doesn't matter). Basicly there might be some galleries that certain members consider gross/inappropriate, so they should be able to remove these galleries from the galleries list OR at least remove all comments(along with images) from "Recent Comments" posted in the said galleries.


Even if you can't answer all questions I'd still appreciate your answer if you have a guess/feeling which of the both scripts would be easier to achieve the desired result with! I just need to decide which one to buy ( or I'll spend so much time comparing them that I could've done the half of the modifications already ^^; )

Thank you in advance!


Also, even if it's a bit off-topic: is it better to have a shared DB for PP/vBG (whichever I decide to buy) and vBulletin or install to PP/vBG on a separate DB?
I hope I don't need to save the images/media files in the DB though (regardless whether it's shared with vB or not) because it might be a bit complicated to restore a huge DB if I need to restore it one day.

[UncoderMom]

I use photplog!! LOVE IT TOO!


http://www.photoplog.com/

[Burns]

Requirements: vBulletin 3.6.0 or greater, (...)

:ermm:

That kind of kills it for me since I'm not willing to upgrade atm (still have a 3.0.7 with many-many modifications).

In fact I did check their site yesterday (didn't even notice the vB 360+ requirement), along with Menalto, Albinator, 4images (never liked Coppermine design, just skipped them).

Even if Photoplog was compatible with vB 3.0.x - what advantages does it have compared to vBG? ( except the price / support(?) )
It has a "Newest Comments" link, but it's not quite what I need, I imagine that it would be almost as hard to hack it as vBG (so that the "Recent Comments" look like in PP).

I see no trace of tags/keywords either ( just like in vBG )

Is the code easier to modify compared with vBG?

Anything else?