vbhacks-germany.de

[Link14716]

Originally Posted by redlabour

At first - we are including a validation Solution ! Of course ... !

@Zachery - if you want or not - one of the GPL Rules are saying definitely that any modification of GPL licensed Software has to be under the same license.
It doesnt make any change if you say that your "Hack" isnt under it.

@all - yes my english isnt so god this Time like that Time i learned it. But it is absolutely good enough to translate English Sentences and words into German.

.

He didn't modify the GPL script in question, he just included it with the download. That is perfectly legal.

[redlabour]

No - it isnt - he is distributing Parts from a GPL Software. Thats enough.

[eva01_]

i would have to see this validation system first hand, before i released my hacks

[Akex]

Originally Posted by redlabour

No - it isnt - he is distributing Parts from a GPL Software. Thats enough.

But the other parts he wrote are not under GPL, so his hack is not under GPL

[Marco van Herwaarden]

Originally Posted by Akex

But the other parts he wrote are not under GPL, so his hack is not under GPL

Only his parts are not under GPL. All other parts are still under GPL (even if he modified it a bit).

[Zachery]

Can you redistribute pjirc? sure, can you redistrubte my intergration? no

[vau7]

I think it doesnt matter if GPL or not - the only Thing i dont understand is the reason why you wont give your agreement.

I dont need this translation and i am not really a part of this project, but i spent some time in the past to translate your Hack for my board. What is the problem for you if somebody else would like to help some others and the hackusers dont have to do this crappy work?

I just cant understand your reasons for this behaviour.

[Dean C]

redlabour - are you planning on taking everyone's modifications here, without asking them, then releasing it in german on your site?

[eva01_]

Originally Posted by vau7

I think it doesnt matter if GPL or not - the only Thing i dont understand is the reason why you wont give your agreement.

I dont need this translation and i am not really a part of this project, but i spent some time in the past to translate your Hack for my board. What is the problem for you if somebody else would like to help some others and the hackusers dont have to do this crappy work?

I just cant understand your reasons for this behaviour.

its his decision he created it, he decides what is done with it.

end of story

[Dean C]

Originally Posted by vau7

I think it doesnt matter if GPL or not - the only Thing i dont understand is the reason why you wont give your agreement.

I dont need this translation and i am not really a part of this project, but i spent some time in the past to translate your Hack for my board. What is the problem for you if somebody else would like to help some others and the hackusers dont have to do this crappy work?

I just cant understand your reasons for this behaviour.

If you made a pot out of clay and painted it black and sold it, would you like it I came along and painted it green and resold it? It's called common courtesy and you don't take others work and distribute it unless you have permission