I really don't like the red on the black. It is sort of unwelcoming.
What I usually suggest to people is two main alternative colors, for a fansite for this children's game, which is http://toontown.com, I would try to use some lightblues, whites, and oranges.
Well,if you see the gears in the backround it has 2 cog users lurking about the site so its kinda of a little fun thing.I do take polls on this,users like the colors (I am thinkning about changing them)...