To enforce a valid coding style in the community!

[sketch42]

Originally Posted by Boofo

But even functionally bad code shouldn't be a hinderance to a newbie. Teaching him how to do it right is altogether different than chastising him in public with some sort of label. That will turn some otherwise good coders off from trying to learn and make it better.

interesting discussion... now i know that i Cant code my way ot of a paper bag.. and if i release a hack (not a template mod :lick: ) i would never expect to pass QA or any other standard... as im not even a begginer , im just struggling to learn enough to understand a quarter of this stuff ... and i dont think that anyone who releases one or two small hacks in their lifetime here would ever think that they would pass QA either... but say by some oddball chance i made a hack and it passed QA.. illtell you that i most likely still cant code my way out of a paper bag.. my point being... who does this benefit.. the coder? the community?

i honestly dont see it benefiting either... as someone who is just beggining to learn all this doesnt really care about neat code.. they want to learn how to code.. and so with time theyll learn, hopefully.

i cant see it benefitting the community because like Satan, Amy and Boofo have previously stated this will more likely create a rift in the community between coders.


so i say No to QA

just my 1/2 a cent