Ok Mr Know it all, Everyone just has to be a smart *** around here.
I know about that field and that is what I have selected already along with the "Yes at registration and profile updating", if it worked I wouldnt be asking this question (original thread), go ahead try getting rid of the issue of those existing members not having anything in this custom private field and are required to enter something in it upon profile updating! This is where the problem lays.
This is why I need this to be for "Yes at registration only". and not "Yes at registration and profile updating".
Doug
I guess you would need a custom modification for that =)