phraseid numbers ..... big problem! ... i warned that this would happen!

[Natch]

I think he was saying that if you want to know what a function does, the best documentation is to look aat the function, and work out what it does.

If this is not something you can do, then your next point of reference is php.net and mysql.com ... that's teh way the rest of us learned how-to.

[Carnage]

Originally Posted by KirbyDE

Worst-Case Scenario:
Jelsoft introduces a new Bit "Is Superadmin" (eg. does have all admin privileges) in usergroup permissions - while your hack used it for <place smth. harmless here>.
Now users unaware of this upgrade and - BANG

i tried that... adding is superadmin requires far too meny code changes to be worth the extra conviniace of being about to superadmin people from the cp.

but yeah i see this point; i suppose this is why hacks are not officially supported... probably the only solution is to warn users of the problems it can (and will?) cause and to make sure that they check permissions etc after installing/upgrading.

or alternativly... use your own bitfield... however myself i quite like the admin permissions bitfield and have added half a dozen new permissions to it for my warnings system and there will probably be more to come...

[Andreas]

Not supporting hacked boards is one thing, "intentionally" increasing the danger of security leaks is another.

As said, this is a hypothetical worst-case scenario and most likely won't ever happen.
But it is far more dangerous to use an unused bit for custom things then adding a column to a table (the upgrade script would crash with a mySQL-error if a column with this name does already exist when they try to ALTER TABLE) or introducing new variables (this can of course also cause problems, but only if Jelsoft uses the same variable name; Bitfields will be used sooner or later)

Btw: Creating such a "issuperadmin" usergroup permission IMHO would be pretty easy: In init.php check the bit, if it is set also set ismoderator and cancontrolpanel.
In can_administer() check that bit and if it is set return true, no matter what $do is.

[bluesteel]

Originally Posted by trafix

How many vb noobs out there would have read this thread and know now that there have been a crash between 2 hacks are wanting to install any hacks now incase it happens to them? i wouldnt be feeling very secure installing any hack to my board atm.....

This issue needs urgent addressing before any more crap happens .... its just as well mycates is relativly experiances with php and db's

He he he trafix.
Spent feckin loads of attempts over the past weeks trying to install your Jukebox hack. Fails every time with a MySQL error. After spending another hour messing about with it tonight, plus coming across this thread, realised that Jukebox is trying to use phraseid 888, which is already in use by the Quiz hack by TWCommish that I have installed.
Bugger!

[trafix]

Originally Posted by bluesteel

He he he trafix.
Spent feckin loads of attempts over the past weeks trying to install your Jukebox hack. Fails every time with a MySQL error. After spending another hour messing about with it tonight, plus coming across this thread, realised that Jukebox is trying to use phraseid 888, which is already in use by the Quiz hack by TWCommish that I have installed.
Bugger!

Oh crap!

Tnx for the feedback bluesteel ...... just goes to show the importance of phraseid number registration .....

you can change the number in the quiry.php and the phrase.php .... where is says 888 change it to another unused phraseid, and it should install

[bluesteel]

No worries mate. Sorta figured that out.
Now I'm off back to the JB hack thread to figure out other small probs

[Carnage]

Originally Posted by KirbyDE

Not supporting hacked boards is one thing, "intentionally" increasing the danger of security leaks is another.

As said, this is a hypothetical worst-case scenario and most likely won't ever happen.
But it is far more dangerous to use an unused bit for custom things then adding a column to a table (the upgrade script would crash with a mySQL-error if a column with this name does already exist when they try to ALTER TABLE) or introducing new variables (this can of course also cause problems, but only if Jelsoft uses the same variable name; Bitfields will be used sooner or later)

Btw: Creating such a "issuperadmin" usergroup permission IMHO would be pretty easy: In init.php check the bit, if it is set also set ismoderator and cancontrolpanel.
In can_administer() check that bit and if it is set return true, no matter what $do is.

Yes well, i'm not going to release the hack in question since i didn't write most of it in the first place... so it'll only be on the board it was written for. In the event of any upgrades, I can easilly change admin permissions if the need arises.

the superadmin user permission is slightly more difficult than that, you have to go through and find every check for the In_array($superadmins_array) thing(can't remember the exact script) and replace it with a check to that permission, however as a quick way to grant all normal permissions, yes it is quite simple.

My intention with it was to have it function in the same way we had root admins function on vb2, root admins were the ones who controlled admin permissions, they were the only ones able to grant access to the admin and root admin forums, plus they had a bunch of other useful things such as the ability to change peoples userid and to add elements to the rpg system we used. However it turned out alot more difficult than i though it would be I may have another go at doing something like this when i've got other things sorted out.

[trafix]

Is something happening with a registration system ??????

I think this is now urgent!!!!

So har now 2 of the 4 major hacks i have released clash phraseid's with another hack.

the members choice clashed with the geek articles hack

and

my jukebox is clashing with some quiz hack.

I WANT YOU TO TELL ME WHAT IS THE POINT OF ME RELEASING ANY MORE HACKS IF I HAVE TO SPEND EVERY SECOND POST HELPING OTHER TO FIX THEIR FORUMS BECAUSE OF CLASHING

[Andreas]

Originally Posted by trafix

Is something happening with a registration system ??????

There is no registration system necessary for phrasetypes ...

[trafix]

so what is your solution that stops clashes?