How can I get rid of 'insert option' window with editor buttons

[psychotica]

I've never run into this problem before. I have always had boards that when you click the [code] [php] [html] buttons, it'll insert the bbcode automatically. I recently installed a board for a friend and the only button that does that now is the Quote button. How can I change it so that all buttons on the editor toolbar will just insert the tags without a need to enter an option, except URL and Emails of course.

anyone have any ideas? I installed sid's hide hack, and it won't add the hide tags without an option entered either.