Paid Subscription not changing title

[countyquest]

I have a test paid subscription entitled "Premium". I paid the fee as one of my test usernames through PayPal and was added to the "Premium" members list. It doesn't change my title from "New Member" to "Premium Member" like I want it to, however.

I chose the Primary Usergroup to be Premium Members and the target group to be Premium Members also. I have also tried other combinations on those settings.

Thanks!