Do forums need a portal?

[Mattwhf]

Hi everyone,

I moved my forum into a sub folder like this /forums/ and replaced homepage with a portal where contains blocks, mix of content from blog and forums. Do you think nowadays, forums should change to a portal, instead of using traditional forum layout?

Thanks in advanced.

[In Omnibus]

I think it depends on the purpose of the forum.

[Mattwhf]

Originally Posted by In Omnibus

I think it depends on the purpose of the forum.

Can you share more details on this?

When needs a portal when its not?

[In Omnibus]

Originally Posted by Mattwhf

Can you share more details on this?

When needs a portal when its not?

That's a long and detailed discussion. Is the purpose of the forum to support the sale of goods or the sale of services? Is the purpose of the forum to engender a community specific to a niche? Is the purpose of the forum no specific purpose, i.e. an off-topic discussion environment?

I think if your forum is a support tool for products, goods, or services you should consider a portal as it allows for access to a website or multiple websites, a forum, an intranet, the internet, third party URLs that may be pertinent or useful, and more.

I think if the main purpose is the forum itself adding a portal is information overload and a distraction to the content.

Obviously, these are my opinions and not necessarily the opinions of others.

As an example, one of the sites I webmaster is specific to one team in one sport. Another is sports general with more than 300 team and individual sports groups. Having a portal for a one niche forum seems like overkill. Having one for a 300 team forum seems like a good idea.

Probably the best way to approach the question is: What would I want to see as a regular user of the forums? Which makes it easier for me to find the information I am seeking?

[gnrx]

What portal are you used with vbulletin forum?

[Mattwhf]

Originally Posted by gnrx

What portal are you used with vbulletin forum?

I like a custom portal that designed by myself.

What my forum are you mentioning?

[gnrx]

Originally Posted by Mattwhf

I like a custom portal that designed by myself.

What my forum are you mentioning?

No, I don't mentioning your forum I was not view your forum, now, in your signature I view your forum.

I asked about CSM because I search a CSM for my vb 4.2.5 and I don't view any, but I can't made some CMS by myself (I don't have the necessary knowledge).

Regards.

[Mattwhf]

Originally Posted by gnrx

I asked about CSM because I search a CSM for my vb 4.2.5 and I don't view any, but I can't made some CMS by myself (I don't have the necessary knowledge).

The best way in this case is, you should find a coder on vB community to do it for you. That can cost a bit but you will have a great portal as your requirement or you like.

[gnrx]

Originally Posted by Mattwhf

The best way in this case is, you should find a coder on vB community to do it for you. That can cost a bit but you will have a great portal as your requirement or you like.

Thanks for the reply.

In this moment, I don't have money for made a cutom CMS, I know that, its better option because the CMS as at my requirement or my like but...in this moment, my money is very little...

Regards.

[redragon29]

Originally Posted by gnrx

Thanks for the reply.

In this moment, I don't have money for made a cutom CMS, I know that, its better option because the CMS as at my requirement or my like but...in this moment, my money is very little...

Regards.

Why you don't use something like wordpress, joomla or other in front of your forum?