Which vB CMS is best

[Darax The Good]

Oh, I do so hate asking questions like this.

Anyway my webpage is currently running php-NUKE. I'm worried about the security track record of nuke, so I'm going to switch to something else. What really makes the most sense is to get one of the CMS hacks for vBulliten.

What I need:
1. The ability to give some people access to posting news, but not all people.

What I would like:
1. A 'daily' poll
2. A top 10 list
3. A reviews manager
4. The ability to make custom blocks
5. The ability to really separate the forum from the home page

You can see my front page here: http://www.friendsofmaddox.com/nuke
and my forum here: http://www.friendsofmaddox.com/vbull

you can see that they are similar, but the size of the tables and icons are different because they serve two different purposes.

Anyway, if you have experience with one of the CMS mods, I'd love to hear about it.

Thanks!

[Dave-G]

I'm sure you will get a fload of replies to this all stating which one is best, so I'll simply list a few and you can visit their sites and make your own mind up.

vbPortal CMS for vB3 - www.vbportal.com
vbAdvanced - www.vbadvanced.com
vbIndex - www.coreforums.net

There are a few other, but I'd say those are the three to look at first.

[dreamhost]

I can't speak for php-nuke as I have never run it before, but I can speak to postnuke.
I have run postnuke for about 2 years now on literally hundreds of client websites. We have never had a single website compromised which is actually shocking to me but true.
From what I understand about the history of the nukes, postnuke came about due to a desire to increase the security of the cms over phpnuke. We have tools like the pnanticracker which checks for injected code and rejects it based upon a set of predefined rules.
There is no such thing as a totally secure application but postnuke does seem to do a fairly good job there. I have found that most security issues are more related to your server setup vs. the cms itself. Take care of those issues first, and your on your way to a fairly solid cms.
We spent months custom coding script connectors that go between postnuke, photopost, vbulletin, and other applications in order to unify the registration and login process. It just wasn't professional to ask people to register 2x in order to use both systems, (imagine having to sign in 2x at msn for your mail, chat etc.... yeah right..).
All I can say is our users absolutelly love the system, and we now get just as much traffic to the pn side as the vb side of the site.

hum... cool opinion on postnuke... i'm happy to see serious reports on my tools...
(ok, i'm one of the former-founders of postnuke, remember it)