hmm I'm sorry if this may sound harsh, but your site looks anything but entertaining. The current colors set a very cold mood for a site that has a purpose to entertain others. You got good content, but your style is not doing any good to it. I mean I got bored just looking at the layout, you know what I mean?
I would recommend a few things, one, try to use warmer colors, add a bit nicer style to your site overal. A better header and a logo would be nice too. Have some contrast in your font colors, your links, text and everything are all almost the same color.
Als your 2 links at the side in the homepage still link to your "betaforums", thought I should let you know
I'm sorry I usually don't respond this way, but I though I should be honest with you about what I think and get my points out. However, this is just my opinion and everyone has different opinion. Don't be discouraged, we all have to start from somewhere
Good luck.