[JTMON]

Originally Posted by tmhall

I referenced the post you quoted her from. If you want to discuss something else she said you should've quoted it.


I never made that assumption, but that is the default configuration of the software. The possible outcome of a case against a hypothetical board with a hypothetical non-default configuration is a little too ambiguous of a discussion for me. Why don't we stick to the subject.


Whether your argument is effective is exactly the point. You keep comparing a piece of software that's used for database administration and happens to allow admins to read PM's with a piece of software designed for reading people's PM's. How do you not see the difference there?


And of course bira destroyed that argument too, when she said:

This isn't rocket science, JTMON. As you pointed out yourself, it all depends on how the specific laws are interpreted by the judge if someone decides to sue you for violating their privacy. It's up to you whether you want to err on the side of caution or stand firm by your "right" to do whatever you want with your board. I'm just pointing out that the smart thing to do is the former.

You did NOT reference the post I made or am talking about. For your info she never even responded to the post I am talking about. You are the one rehashing an old old old argument and making the EXACT same points as others so you should go digging I think. I replied to the actual law, which she posted, you are replying to replies..

Since this whole forum is about changing the default configuration of your board I wouldn't think that coversation would be that far fetched. As for the differences in the software...the software is not illegal by iteself..it may or may not be depending on how you use it. The same should/would go for PhPMyAdmin....if the sole reason someone installed PHPMA was to read user PMs then I believe it would fall under that same law....You can't tell me you wouldn't still be arguing your point if this hack was just part of some bigger hack with more features which would then make it more like PHPMA soley because it also has OTHER uses.....at any rate I'm done arguing the same arguement for the third time I think it is during the life of this hack...As for the checkbox saying you read the privacy agreement, it's about as binding as software EULAs....