[kgroneman]

Thanks Dave, that's what I thought too, but when I use just forumid I get the same error:

Message
An error occurred while attempting to execute your query. The following information was returned. 
error number: 1054 
error desc: Unknown column 'forumid' in 'where clause'

Any other ideas? Oh interesting...on a different query, forumid works. I wonder why not on this query? Off to try some other things but if you have any ideas, they would be most appreciated.