[Logician]

Very likely it's 2, have you tried that?

To be sure:

Login Admin CP/ USER GROUPS/ Modify / Find the user group you want in the list, right mouse click on its edit menu, choose open in new browser window and check the address bar. You'll see at the end of line as: "usergroupid=X"

I mean assuming I had the correct number in the past, I should have been able to see it regardless, me having admin rights, don't you think so?

Nope certainly NOT! If you set it to 2 only usergroup with 2 can see it. If you want to display it to eg. usergroup 2 AND 6 you have to modify the line:

if ($bbuserinfo[usergroupid]==2 AND $bbuserinfo[usergroupid]==6)