With all you have done to your place the logo is lacking.
A logo is what people will see first and what they will remember. It's a reflection of your forum.
It's needs passion, flair, soul. It needs to say who you are with a bold and confident air about it.
What you have is a font template. If you're not any good with graphics do what I did, cheat!
You can go to
www.cooltext.com or
www.flamingtext.com (same outfit I think) and make you something in text that looks a lot better.
http://www.animeappeal.com/?styleid=125