Hi TalkVirginia,
Yes, I have the webmaster field filled in. As I stated earlier, when it doesn't have any inactive users to send me to, the report email looks fine and it comes "from" my forum name. It's only when it has inactive users that the "from" fields are send as blanks. If the name of my forum or wbmaster email were missing in my settings, I don't think it would ever have a "from" sender right?
As requested, here are some screenshots of my settings (one of them is altered for privacy, but you get the idea). If you need anything else let me know.