So, you want it so if users go to index.php, they get shown the forumid 4 forumdisplay page instead? Just leave forumdisplay.php and index.php alone and create a plugin like:
hook - global_bootstrap_init_start
PHP Code:
if (THIS_SCRIPT == 'forumdisplay') $_REQUEST['forumid'] = 4; //4 is the forumid I want to use.
See if that does what you want.
Set index.php to go to forumdisplay.php (line 62) also.