[wajones]

Originally posted by chrispadfield
I know of only one vb board that has restricted membership to only paying customers and that is paintballcity.com and it has worked well apparently.

To be able to do that you really need a forum with little competition or a unique selling point, quite hard to have at the moment. I don't think forcing people to pay is the best option unless you have something very special but encouraging a subscription for some extra benefit does work.

Your right, that's about it in a nutshell, for every site that charges there will be more than a few offering the same or better service for free.

The only thing I can see is that if you have a popular board, the membership may want a private area that their willing to help maintain with contributions. Keeps out the people that just frequent to disrupt things, that could be a perk in itself. But then you would have the problem of enticing new members ???

Sounds like a no win situation.