No dismas, its not true in a large forum 170K members, like mine we need to monitor members posts, and when our staffs check their posts, first thing we do we look at their ID to know if he is one of our old member or not.. this save u a lot of time and no need to keep checking profiles.. and its true with SEO u will see links rather members id..
Photo
http://img132.imageshack.us/my.php?image=idvs4.png