[eJM]

Originally Posted by jaycob

well if IP.Boards are allowed to do it the last few years, then so can we yeah?

Congratulations. You have caused Ziki to edit the description back to the way it was, without the disclaimer. I don't use IPBoards, so I wouldn't know if what you say is true or not. I do use Google and the quote I provided above comes from here: http://www.google.com/support/webmas...n&answer=66355 No, it doesn't use the exact term "Guests", but then it doesn't use many other terms that might imply the same thing. It uses "users." Why don't you provide the same sort of "proof?"

... what you told Ziki to add is going to scare everyone off from using this addon completely.
yeah agreed, be safe, but bring on the proof first.

Exactly. Where's your proof? Look, this debate could go on and on. If you want to have a debate about what Google and other search engines like and don't like, start a new topic. I merely agreed with at least one other very experienced webmaster that the possibility exists that this mod is in violation of Google terms. The debate rages on and unless we get a definitive answer from Google itself, regarding the practice of allowing it to index content that its users will click the link to and get an error message instead of the content, then neither you nor I will have the "proof."

As I said before, that you apparently didn't read even though you quoted it, it's my opinion that Ziki has an ethical responsibility to his customers to warn them of the possibilities. I've got nothing to gain or lose by keeping people from using this mod. It's only my desire to help my fellow webmasters who may be looking for legitimate ways to bring relevant content, including advertising, to my users. This product does not appear to be that and it may be detrimental to my ranking and indexing in Google and other search engines.

I'm taking a wild guess here that, based on the content of your avatar and signature, you're prob'ly around a teenager. I don't know how much experience you have as a webmaster, but mine goes back to about the time you were born (in other words, in the teens). I'm old and I hope I am wise in some matters. My personal rulZZZ: don't argue with children. I'm done with this conversation.