Okay, first of all, it looks pretty good to me, at least design wise. Since my knowledge of the topic and what the fans like is non existant, I can't really say if it captures the mood the members expect, so well done anyway.
Looks good activity wise, and all the forums are filled up with posts. Member count and post count is good as well, so well done on that regard.
Smilies are good, although you may want a few related to the forum's topic and music as a whole, since they're a bit generic, and it's a good move to have a video vB code for a music based forum.
Nice default avatar choices as well, plenty of them being about the celebrity which the forum is about.
However, while the splash page and image looks nice, it's pretty much useless as far as both members and SEO is concerned, so I'd think having a home page with more in the way of content would help in both these aspects.
All in all though, good, not much to criticise.
|