[Lea Verou]

Originally Posted by Marco van Herwaarden

Maybe i don't understand you, but what you describe is exactly how we have it on vB.org.

Was this changed recently? I'm sure I can recall quite a lot mods that do stuff that can be done with just a template modification being in add-ons.

Originally Posted by Marco van Herwaarden

Suggest an objective, fair, practical and usefull for all community members rule to govern such a thing and we will think about it. But that is almost impossible, so very unlikely to ever happen.

See above.

As I said above, I can't think of a solution for that, but I don't think the problem is unsolvable.
A quick idea that just popped into my head would be a voting system that every hack would have by default, and coders would vote whether it should go to the other category. Perhaps something like the "petition to change bug status to..." on project tools, only it would be "petition to change mod category to...".
Or perhaps the separation could be done the other way around, to have a category for "best hacks" and every mod after a number of votes (or rating-based) would be automatically moved to that category. Probably these aren't good ideas, I'm sure there are better ways to do this...
I guess though if it only bothers me, I'll just sit quietly in my corner...

@Boofo: Stop underestimating yourself please. Thanks.