Jason it's great to hear your thoughts on your fantastic hack.
Please don't remove *any* functionality. It works perfectly on
www.avforums.com and in my opinion, the closer you can make it to ebay's trading system (with rebuttals) the better since that is what people are used to and will feel familiar with.
We require both parties to have posted in the thread with one of them having started it - as per standard functionality of your hack. This is awesome because it discourages people from hijacking wanted threads (i.e. they can't leave feedback).
To overcome the occasional problem of people struggling to enter the correct trade link, I created a tutorial video which anyone is welcome to use:
http://www.avforums.com/tutorials/le...g_feedback.wmv
Although having some way of doing the job without entering the thread URL would be infinitely better.