I tested it and apparently I do have the right template, but those fields are still not showing up. I also did some checking to make sure I did everything right with the plug-in (since I'm new at this) and it looks like all you do is upload it, correct? Everything looks right to my untrained eye.

Any thoughts?
By the way, do you think this will slow things down? Is that what you were concerned about with it querying the database for all the users? (Again, I'm still learning). I am having a major issue with my site being slow right now, so I am scared of anything slowing it down further. But, I guess I could always take it out if it caused problems.
Thanks again for your help!