talash,
I disagree. I don't feel that I "bashed" your company in any way. The only thing that I said that would be taken as "bashing" was when I stated that some of the sites in your portfolio were broken, and not using valid code. But if that's fact, it's not bashing. I was simply letting him know that I wasn't impressed with it. There's a lot more to websites than just a pretty face.
I never mentioned anything about poor craftsmanship, but in my opinion, a good craftsman would develop results that work in all browsers, and stay up to date with web standards. You are, after all, a web company. But I didn't bring that up, you did.
So it turns out I was right about everything except that you would say, "Yes, we can do that!" when you actually can't. My mistake. I've seen that happen just about 95% of the time, so I felt I was safe to assume it true in this case too.
But no, I won't contact and verify with a company just to answer a question on here if I didn't feel right about it. Who would? It's merely my opinion and I thought I made that clear by adding "My two cents" to the end of my post.