it depend on what you require, sincerely...

1- taste of the visitors... (visitors, not clients, are usually just lurking, so forget it!)

2- taste of the members... your members may have an opinion on the look of your site, so maybe providing both versions of your skin is the best solution.

3- your own vision of the site... if you decide that your site is not to be decided by your visitors or members, do what you like most.. remember, the design of your site is supposed to reflect what YOU think of that site...

fixed OR fluid have the same problem.. they have to fit in all browsers...

--------------- Added [DATE]1197238726[/DATE] at [TIME]1197238726[/TIME] ---------------

oh, btw, add the Elastic Design to your poll..