[NolF]

Well I've found couple of interesting things. One is a serious bug, which never came to my mind, but has to be fixed :O because is a big one aye

[bug 1]

When u give karma to someone, you use this link
./karma.php?do=processvote&u=$$$$&rating=4
But if you use firefox (works on ie too u just have to bother yourself coping the link word for word), and copy the link, you cna change that number to any number, for example 100, and it will give 100 karma points to that user. if you put -1000 it will take 1000 points from that user :O

I wonder how one of my users figured it out, but very cleaver indeed. The creep didn't even report it, but there you go

[bug? 2]
I'm pretty sure it is how you intended it to, but, is a bit ehhh to classify inactive users as not having opted to participate in the system. I mean, in the stats page the part which says "users have chosen to not participate in the Karma system. Shame on them!"
In my personal opinion, only active users, who have opted not to participate should be counted here.

[Suggestion 1]
Okey this suggestion, is better than any of the previous 3 ^^
When you give karma, you are redirected to the members profile, but my users (at least) find it quite annoying. I guess vBulletin has made them used to been redirected to the same page they were at.

[Suggestion 2]
At the moment, in order to calculate karma averages, you are using the old fashion add all scores and divide by the number. However, it is not the same to have 100 votes and an average of 4 than having 5 votes and an average of 5.
I recon a formula such as the one used on imdb.com is more aquarate than the current formula

Originally Posted by imdb

weighted rating (WR) = (v ? (v+m)) ? R + (m ? (v+m)) ? C

where:
R = average for the movie (mean) = (Rating)
v = number of votes for the movie = (votes)
m = minimum votes required to be listed in the Top 250 (currently 1300)
C = the mean vote across the whole report (currently 6.7)

Variables, I guess should be determined via ACP, or calculated to correspond with the votes flux

[Comment]
I run a Spanish forum, so I had to translate the phrases, I just wanted to say, it was quite complicated at times to translate them, because it wasn't intuitive from the names, and the original English sentence what the purpose of the phrase was.
Also in many cases, you just put a word/sentence, which will be followed by a variable (ie number username etc) and dont use the {1} that makes it quite complicated to translate in many languagues
I could do a list if you are interested

Thx for listening ^^