@Zom.. at your place, i would make myself moving like a ghost, like nobody know you're there ok... you were not asked to laugh about the content of his site... you can compare with your index page with no content at all...
actually, i visited your site... cool community, a large membership.
i would tend to go with a Runescape-like style actually, instead of your pre-made skin... members would be more like home... but it looks like a good place for unlocking the runescape means..

(my 10 years old son is playing RS regulary, he is a paying member)