I agree with you, the site at the moment, is very simple, and is "safe, ... but it is not customized to your site.....
I am part of a clan, and i find the idea of this pretty good!, as i run clan tournaments within Counter-strike, ... You need to know what your focus is, look at some other gaming sites or clan sites, and try use the colour schemes, get some good icons, ;0 - youre site will soon customize itself
Greg