i see some hackers want to sell hacks but can they do this ?
the vb license allow people to sell hacks ?

you can sell a script when you write all the code but hacks cannot work without vb.

Any info about this ?

Its their PHP code and their modifications so therefore i think they should have the right to do so.

The liscence agreement doesn't specify the selling of hacks.

So far my big hacks are all basically standalone scripts that interface with the VB, rather than modifying VB code.

Yeah, they modify code a bit, but the core of it is a standalone file.

yep but just an exemple of karma hack or vbportal.
Without vBulletin they cannot work, but how somebody can sell a script to someone when you need also to pay vb.

Just to make it a bit clearer: You don't pay for the scripts. You donate to keep up the project. vbPortal 2.01 is available for free. vbPortal will also be free as soon as it gets out of Beta. However, those who don't donate won't get support from phpportals.com

Well if you want to look at it that way, if it weren't for php, mysql, the server, it's operation system, your computer, and Microsoft Windows or what ever operation system and browser your using vBulletin wouldn't work. That doesn't mean they can't sell vbulletin.

I'm not defending a particular thing here except the right to get compensated for your time if you feel you want or need compensated.
Just look at it as services rendered, if a particular person writes a hack and you want it. He is of no obligation to give it to you free or otherwise.
On the other hand if he offers it to you for a charge, you are not obligated to buy it.
Just because you want it and you want it free doesn't make it wrong for someone to charge for their services.

If it were just a matter of developing hacks, I don't think anybody would charge a dime.

However, you also end up supporting any hacks you develop. Quite often, the people that you are supporting have no clue about what they are doing and it ends up becoming a logistical nightmare.

I have seen people struggle just to install the board - to the point of having to pay to have it done, and they they want to dive in and start hacking it up.

Personally, I don't believe an author should release a hack unless they intend to support it. Look at all the abandoned hacks scattered around the forum. There are many hacks with page after page of support questions without a peep from the author in response.

Thus, I would rather have an author release a paid hack, and provide adequate support than see a hack released by somebody who has neither the time nor the inclination to support their work.

On a final note, I tend to think everyone who downloads hacks and uses hacks should be contributing to the hacking community in some way. I am not good enough yet to release anything worthwhile, so I try to help others with questions and problems. Some people are good at graphic arts. Others are good programmers. Everyone in this community has some talent or resource that can be shared.

Amy

No no no

i never said that i wnt free hack so charge service was a mistake.
I just want to know if something in the license talk about that.
Because the hack community grow up but if everybody do something different it will become a big mess

[QUOTE]Originally posted by amykhar
If it were just a matter of developing hacks, I don't think anybody would charge a dime.

Firefly,
I never said it was easy :D It's just fun. I don't mind doing fun things, and don't generally think about asking to get paid for things I enjoy doing. Hmmm, maybe that's why I'm so damn broke. :D

Amy