Banning users from a public site.
 

Well, i have to say if your running a private site, banning works just fine.

But i run a public site, and there may be members I wish to ban for whatever reason...
the problem is that they can simply re-register again no matter what I do to ban them, or they can use a proxy and register again.

How do you ban someone permenantly from a publicly accessible site?

Everytime they register you simply keep banning them, eventually they will get tired of playing games

With repeat evaders, I usually threaten to or contact the ISP and that works wonders.

Trust me on this one... neither of the two above mentioned suggestions are going to work for the particular member i am thinking of.

not too much u can do other than maybe closing your registration for a week and see if he finally gives up.

if he's someone going incognito each time he comes back, u could also try the AE Detector mod.

thats the best option, check theadminzone.com for more information to manage such miserable users.

I installed dmenteds RBL hack... but im not sure if that will work too wel, and i may remove.

ill look into the one you mentioned rich.

I wonder how this would apply to foreign users, in eastern Europe for example. Would their ISP even care that a member is spamming your forum?

speaking of "miserable" the Miserable User mod is good one to try.

another that is built into vBulletin is called Tachy Goes to Coventry.

look under vBulletin Options / User Banning Options

In all honesty, there is nothing that you can do to stop someone registering on your site if they determined to do so short of disabling registrations all together.

Sooner or later the person will give up, but you need to have good staff who can keep banning as quick as the person is registering. The only problem is that depending on the determination of the person concerned, this can go on for weeks, if not longer.

Moderation of accounts is useful, but only really if the same IP address is used each time, but then an IP ban would solve than problem anyway. Moderation of posts by the registered users group is also useful, but it isn't really going to be suitable for active sites that get a number of new registrations every day.

(Oh and I know the exact member type you are referring too here)

I agree with that, the trouble is they will just use a proxy as way to get around the IP bans and use free email sevice to register with bogus email addresses.

So there's not really a lot you can do if they start doing that.

the answer is Miserable Users Hack ;)

There are actually a number of hacks available which combat users using proxies.

This one converts the proxy ip to the users real ip and allows vbulletin's IP address functions (including IP address banning) to function based on what the hack determines as the user's "real ip"

https://vborg.vbsupport.ru/showthread.php?t=120082

The other one works by merely banning all open proxies outright... in my experience taking this action is extremely effective, however, it negatively effects just about anyone without a static email address. (When I implemented it, one of my most loyal members could not access the site for a month because they used AOL... it wasn't this particular hack but a vbulletin 3.0.0 alternative though.)

https://vborg.vbsupport.ru/showthread.php?t=96318

I love Tachy Goes To Coventry and have used it many times as an effective tool for thwarting a member who insists on being part of the community.

Basically they are allowed to join and rant to their hearts content, but no other member has to deal with them. When somebody gets sent to Coventry, it usually takes them days or weeks to figure out that they are being ignored. In that respect, sending them to Coventry gets them off your back for longer than a brute-force banning.

I agree that for the most part keeping a determined user off your board is going to come down to a test of endurance between the user and you and your Mod team. My Mod team loves this particular game and so not too much gets past them.

It is just a thought...but if you set your new registered user level to have all messages moderated then nobody can join up and post rubbish..

As you trust people you can move them on to a higher level without the moderation.

Steve

i like the coverty idea... i might try it.

ive got the RBL hack installed, and the one mentioned here.

miserable users is next when i sort out these retarded other problems im having heh.

one big problem is... im the mod team....
and this user is mostly here to steal shit from me, then he is to post rubbish...