Originally Posted by Rock Anthony (Post 2178934)

Two things for me render this product unusable for my site:

1. Failed registrations provide no visible feedback to the user.

If a registration fails, only if the KeyCAPTCHA puzzle is solved does the system alert the user of why the registration failed.

Under the default human verification system of vbulletin, the system immediately alerts the user of why a registration failed (mismatch password, invalid email address, incorrect CAPTCHA, etc.)

The 'registration' button is at the bottom of the registration page. When the user scrolls to the bottom to click the button, the KeyCAPTCHA image is no longer in view. The only alert KeyCAPTCHA provides for an incorrect puzzle solution is the display of a red crossed out circle. This red crossed out circle is not in view because the user has scrolled to the bottom of the page. So, the registration fails, and with no visible feedback provided, the user is left clueless as to why the page does nothing. The user can of course scroll back up, but the red crossed out circle displays for a couple of seconds and then disappears, most likely before a user scrolls back up. Eventually a new user would figure this out, as did I, but I would rather not frustrate new users that try to register - they might leave.

This would definetly work to stop spam bots, but also to frustrate new users

Originally Posted by DvDaf (Post 2185213)

Thank you, this is perfect!