What makes you think its not working ?

It works great, but there seems to be a small bug. When giving a negative reputation without a comment it returns the error message that you'd get when giving a positive reputation without a comment. It should probably tell the user that they can't give a NEGATIVE reputation without a comment to avoid confusion.

This does not force comments on Negative Reputation, thats built into vb by default.

Sorry, I should have clarified a little. I know that it is an inbuilt feature of vBulletin to force comments on negative reputation. However, my issues lies within:

Where, without a comment inputted into the field, it will return a "You must enter a reason to give positive reputation." notification. That's a part of the mod's "Require Positive Reputation Comment" feature. I can see why it does this, but it seems like a confusing notification to give to a user who believes they are leaving a negative reputation.

That again is vbulletin, not the mod.

By default vbulletin assumes 0 to be positive, and therefore gives the positive comment. There is nothing can be done about that since it has to assume one or the other, and generally (+) is more likely to be correct than (-).

If its an isue then simply edit the positive message to remove any reference to +/-, but rather just say a comment is required. :)

This is a great mod. Hopefully you'd consider adding a new option where users can choose how much reputation they can give not exceeding their total cap. Similar to an abandoned mod somewhere in the old version of vB.

Nice one! thank you. Any chance you can make a lite version of hook that only works on allow/disable reputation for particular forums? The beer is on me(stouth, ale..) underline the appropriate one :) Old Trip???