Disable it from the config then check permissions
Redirect blank = No
In the Proxy Alert: Permissions add the groups you dont want to see the alerts. I put all member groups in there only left out groups 1, 3, 4 and 8

Fix (I thought) all of the settings. But, if I have it set to yes on globally, still getting blank page.

Post screenshot of all settings

Removed.

Proxy Alert: General
Enabled = Yes
Tor = Yes
Lan Proxy = Yes
Web Proxy = Yes
Members Only = Yes
Template Edits = Yes
Redirection = Yes
Redirect Blank = No
Page Message = <span style="color:red;">You were detected using a proxy! For security reasons, we do not allow this on our community. Please disable the proxy or switch browsers if it is built in. Thank you.</span> or leave it the way you have it
Page Message Color = leave this blank
Persistent = Yes
Cookie Time = 365
Location = No
Message = Proxies are frowned upon in our community, please disable this or change browsers. Thank you.
Message Color = white

Proxy Alert: Registrations
Registration = Yes
Registration Only = Yes
Registration Remember = Yes

Proxy Alert: Email
Email = No

Proxy Alert: Thread
Thread = No
Forum ID = leave blank
User ID = leave blank

Proxy Alert: Permissions
IP Whitelist = I would leave this blank

That is pretty much how I have it set, except if I set it on, it blocks out one of my Super Mods, and they are not behind any Proxy. So, that is why I have their IP in there. Plus...set like you posted, I get a blank screen, and everyone does.

Oh well, pretty much looks like I can't use it. At least it wasn't expensive.

Thank you so much for your help.

Oh...hmmm would any other Proxy hack be interfering? I do have another one it.....Proxy to Real IP.

You could have another plugin causing a problem with it don't just disable the one you think is messing with it remove it fully

I tried it all, and it doesn't seem to matter. If I set it globally, I get the blank page. Guess this one is not for me.

globally?

Yes, the first one in the long list of settings. Under General.