Now, I had some time to test drive vBExperience.
Here are some suggestions:
- Display levels overview (how many points you need to reach a certain level)
- Adjust breadcrump to vb' s look. Right now it looks like
homepage - forum
L vbexperience earn points
Whereas it should look like
homepage - forum - vbexperience
L earn points
- Earn points for profile views (your own profile viewed by someone else).
- Earn points for viewing album pictures.
- Earn points for commenting album pictures.
- Only earn points for received renomee, when positive renomee. Substract if negative?
- Earn points for poll creation.
- Earn points for received votes.
- Earn points for voting.
- Earn points for calendar events.
- Earn points for avatar upload.
- Earn points for profile picture upload.
- Earn points for signature.
- Earn points for birthday.
- Earn points for custom profile fields.
- Earn points for social group message.
- Earn points for social group picture.
- Earn points for private messages. Our users should use the visitor message feature in the first place. Therefore we like to substract points when a user sends a private messages.
- It looks like you cannot set negative user points for actions. It would be nice to be able to do so, because by doing so, you would be able to limit certain actions. Eg private messaging, attachment views, creation of visitor messages, gallery views, etc.
- Do not allow negative values for user points. This is to support the use of negative points for certain actions. Let' s say I have set negative points for private messages, users should not be able to send out private messages if they have less points than the substracted amount for sending private messages.
- Starting balance and monthly balance for points. Eg if you set negative points for pms, new users would not be able to pm other people right away. Therefore they should get a certain amount of points for the beginning. To keep users participating on the forums, they should get a certain amount of points each month (like a paycheck).
- Donations of points. Our members liked this feature pretty much. You were able to donate your own points to someone else.
- Negative values will mess up the system quite a lot. Recounting points would most likely lead to false values. Eg by deleting private messages, you would be able to regain private message sending ability.
I noticed some problems with the level import, if you do not uninstall the level first it sometimes does not update the levels. If you uninstall first, recounting seems to be enough. No need to update points on the maintenance screen.
Is it possible that the instructions for finding the right level setting are not correct? These are the instructions:
Quote:
What level would you advise with X members?
These depends on many other factors. Just import a product, run a recount and take a look at the rankings:
- Top Members are up to level 30-40: Import a higher level.
- Top Members are up to level 60-70: Great. Just keep the level.
- Top Members are up to level 80: There is only small room for growing.
- Top Members are above level 90: Take a lower level.
|
I think if you get 30-40 for your top users, you need to pick a lower level (if you used level 4, try using level 3). If you do the other way around your top levels will be smaller than 30-40.
If you get levels above 90, you should take a higher level. After the recount you should get levels below 90.
I would suggest taking a lower level, too, if you get top levels of up to 80. Then your top members will probably have a level of up to 60, which would give them the chance to participate in vBExperience a little bit longer.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Phalynx
(Post 1646897)
I have no clue. It's definitly working with 3.8 Beta 1.
|
I did not know that. I thought it did not work, because you said that beta 3 will be adapted to 3.8 beta 1. I guess you meant the new features of vb 3.8. Then I might try updating to vb 3.8 before your next vbexperience release.
Quote:
Originally Posted by crazzyustad
(Post 1646856)
u got me wrong, i am talking about promotion by activity meter and not by the point system.
The fault of the point system is that once a user reaches a certain point value, he is promoted to a particular group, but after that he can remain inactive and enjy all the facilities.
But by activity meter, he/she always have to be active
|
I see. But I think you need to take other things into consideration, too. Right now, I am testing a new install and imported data from the real site. Therefore only the test users I log into have an activity of more than 50 %. But it is not hard to get over 50 %. I think if you register a new account and login daily, you will even get 100% activity.
|