I will check I never messed with the User Picture Storage

Just see what it says, maybe take a screenshot of that.

maybe thats why the custom avatars were not showing up in the active stream, members list, and arcade

--------------- Added [DATE]1377385331[/DATE] at [TIME]1377385331[/TIME] ---------------

I don't know whats wrong with my paint it wont paste so I can save a screenshot is there another way?

I don't know, that is the only way I do it. There is probably browser extensions that allow you to do so though.

File Path - ./customavatars
URL to avatars - customavatars
profile picture path - ./customprofilepics
URL to profile picture - customprofilepics
Sig picture path - ./signaturepics
URL to sig pic - signaturepics

Ok, so they re being served from the database, are those folders present and writable (usually chmod 0777)

Here is a URL of a member whos custom avatar is showing

http://armorgaming.com/member.php?266-AG-Disrupt-AC

I am not seeing his avatar either.

Im not sure not all that familiar with databases files present and whiteable what more will I be looking for?

That may not even be the problem though. Like I said earlier, some are being read from the database and some are being read from the filesystem. I would wait till someone else replies here that may know more, or has come across such a issue.