Yeah the guest/signup think gets annoying after a few pages.
At any rate, I really like the appearance and feel of your forum, and I don't even have an interest in fish tanks. Great color and graphics usage. I found it easy to navigate although I couldn't find where in the world you're located.
The DIY projects caught my attention. Some interesting stuff. Electronic projects always have been an interest of mine.

Thanks! I just changed its behavior so it will stay closed. I think I am going to attempt another solution rather than have the pop up.

--------------- Added [DATE]1339126016[/DATE] at [TIME]1339126016[/TIME] ---------------

I also made some other tweeks to the site in the past couple days including

An animated background.

I also tweeked some other forum display pages:

http://www.captivereefs.com/forum/tank-month/

http://www.captivereefs.com/forum/coral-collector/

this one is the most "stock looking" http://www.captivereefs.com/forum/basics/


Also made it so the forum icons show on the search page: http://www.captivereefs.com/forum/se...daily&days=100


Curious to get more feedback on the site.

I just added a custom welcome banner and removed the annoying guest/signup thing.

Any review would be appreciated.
http://www.captivereefs.com/forum/forums.html

Really good job with it. Beautiful design, easy to brand, it's clear what the site is about. Top notch work ;)