honest opinion

[Zachery]

im working on this project and i got a nice style done and the director of the project couldnt contionue and now i have this guy wanting to change the whole layout


http://viper.viperhost.com/~thelock/test/forum.php?&styleid=1
thats the one i made
http://viper.viperhost.com/~thelock/test/forum.php?&styleid=4
thats the one he is insiting we use, its slightly modifed from the original site :\

what do you guys think

[narusaga]

ugh....I dont really like both (no offense). The colors are so diffrent it kinda looks plain.

http://viper.viperhost.com/~thelock....php?&styleid=4
if I had to pick I would choose that one. ^^.

[Zachery]

the original buttons arnt up for the blue one :(

[M1th]

I dont like the styleid=4 one because the colours dont match at all.

the first one looks much better..you will change the buttons which is good.
Just a suggestion for the text links.. they dont go well on a grey/silver-ish background.. playaround with the colours..(eg. black might look better).

So, overall I prefer the first style. :)

[Tony G]

First Style:

No offense, but it's not very appealing. The table colors do not match with the background colors at all. It looks horrible there. Also, the locker image in the banner is a neat idea but you could have used some better font to finish it off. Also, make it stretch across the whole screen.

Second Style:

Bit better, black background does not match this time. But the inside colors do. Except for the blue, get rid of that. The Green is not too good at blending in, but it'd do. :)

[mx3]

I like the first better....i just don't like the colors for the 2nd one...