View Full Version : [sug] new rating for modifications
Dream
06-21-2005, 06:21 PM
would be cool if you could rate mods on a 1-10 scale like the pic.
Xenon
06-21-2005, 06:41 PM
aren't 5 stars enough?
Dream
06-21-2005, 06:43 PM
you could rate it 7.8 then :P not the stars
Princeton
06-21-2005, 08:11 PM
actually, 3 would be enough -> agree, neutral, disagree
Erwin
06-21-2005, 10:19 PM
The number of installs is enough. :)
Logikos
06-22-2005, 12:10 AM
The number of installs is enough. :)
Agreed!
eXtremeTim
06-22-2005, 02:12 AM
I think the rating would be nice for the quality of the hack. ;)
Guest190829
06-22-2005, 02:36 AM
I don't think Erwin and Xenon need more work! :ermm:
Paul M
06-22-2005, 02:42 AM
The number of installs is enough. :)Not really. There is no perfect system to rate a hack, each has its problems.
The number of installs can depend on how specialised the hack is (and how old it is). It cannot cope with one person having multiple installs if they have multiple forums. New members of vb.org often don't use it, because they don't know about it. Other people simply forget. Some people click install yet never use the hack.
The ratings is a very underused system - 5/10/15 stars will make no difference - few people will ever use it (most hacks have never been rated).
HOTM - is an what I call an "of the moment" popularity contest. A hack can, by your measure of installs, be very popular, yet never get close to being a HOTM - while a winner of it can be abandoned or forgotton just a few months after it was "the best thing since sliced bread".
Each has it's merits, but none is suitable for all.
Not really. There is no perfect system to rate a hack, each has its problems.
The number of installs can depend on how specialised the hack is (and how old it is). It cannot cope with one person having multiple installs if they have multiple forums. New members of vb.org often don't use it, because they don't know about it. Other people simply forget. Some people click install yet never use the hack.
The ratings is a very underused system - 5/10/15 stars will make no difference - few people will ever use it (most hacks have never been rated).
HOTM - is an what I call an "of the moment" popularity contest. A hack can, by your measure of installs, be very popular, yet never get close to being a HOTM - while a winner of it can be abandoned or forgotton just a few months after it was "the best thing since sliced bread".
Each has it's merits, but none is suitable for all.
Not to mention that HOTMs have been known to have severe security holes.
I suggested it a couple of years ago and I'll suggest it again: create a vb.org 'committee' to give ratings/reviews of uploaded hacks/plugins.
Erwin
06-22-2005, 10:17 AM
Not to mention that HOTMs have been known to have severe security holes.
I suggested it a couple of years ago and I'll suggest it again: create a vb.org 'committee' to give ratings/reviews of uploaded hacks/plugins.
We did try that. :) The idea was good but it fizzled out - it's harder than it sounds to do in practice.
Chris M
06-22-2005, 11:49 AM
Why not give it another try?:)
Satan
We did try that. :) The idea was good but it fizzled out - it's harder than it sounds to do in practice.Really? I don't remember there being a system in place here for that?
What kind of issues did you find that made it difficult?
Cheers,
~Regs.
Really? I don't remember there being a system in place here for that?
What kind of issues did you find that made it difficult?
Cheers,
~Regs.
Generally getting people involded. You didn't see it because it never got off the ground. At first it seemed like a lot of people where intrested, but as time wen't on it seemed like no one had time to do it.
It's 'hard to do in practice' because it is hard to find people willing to support it and stick with it.
Wouldn't it just basically be a Mod position here?
I mean, how many current vB team members started out just a regular coders here? Quite a few, no?
Why not offer a few selected coders here a Mod position and get Jelsoft to donate a couple of licenses for them?
Just some suggestions/thinking out loud as I still really think this place would benefit ten-fold with a review system and would like to encourage further discussion on the topic.
Then again, it appears that I'm getting censored a bit around here lately due to some thoughts I posted on vB.com so I'll just go back to lurking for awhile.
Cheers,
~Regs.
Censored?
Anyway the problem lies in finding people that not only have the time to do this, but also have the experance to review others code correctly. Most of the coders here spend a lot of time making stuff for themselves, release/support modifications here in their free time, and all this while trying to keep up with 'day to day' life.
Honestly the things these people would have to do for this to work I wouldn't want to do myself, it is just time consuming. Sure jelsoft can kick a few free licenses their way but that does not put food on the table.
At the end of the day it basicly comes down to lack of time, and by begin a part of this project would mean giving up other things. I fear these 'other things' would include no longer having the time to support your own hacks or write your own code.
It's a great idea in concept and no one will tell you otherwise, we see the benifit, the trouble as I've said if finding people willing to do it with the experance and free time needed.
vBulletin® v3.8.12 by vBS, Copyright ©2000-2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.